Under regular conditions, private health insurers are restricted to adjusting their rates only once annually, following official approval by the federal health minister. However, a recent report from the Commonwealth Ombudsman reveals a trend known as “product phoenixing.”
This scheme permits insurers to discontinue a specific policy to new customers while rolling out another, albeit similar, policy at a steeper cost. This maneuver situates insurers favorably, allowing them to implement what Health Minister Mark Butler terms a “sleight of hand.” It stymies consumer freedom, making transitions between different insurers onerous.
"It is clearly against the spirit of the law and it is an under-handed, largely secret, way of health insurers raising their prices," Minister Butler stated during a press conference in Canberra.
Analyzing the effects, it shows that many Australians inadvertently support these price manipulations. New customers typically bear an extra $38 monthly in premium charges alongside $184 in additional fees, as calculated by market observers. This trend is notably widespread among top-tier ‘gold’ insurance policies, designed to provide enhanced services including maternity and mental health care.
A concrete instance of this tactic surfaced when an insurer terminated existing gold policies, subsequently releasing near-identical policies marked up by 21% relative to their predecessors in 2023. This practice persisted into 2024, with a further 14% price surge documented.
Brett Heffernan of the Australian Private Hospitals Association echoes the widespread dissatisfaction: "Is anyone surprised insurance companies are gouging their members like they gouge hospitals?" His candid remarks underscore the pressing crisis facing both public and private healthcare facilities, aggravated by financial strains attributed to inadequacies in insurer contributions versus burgeoning waiting lists.
Examining this issue further uncovers how deeply intertwined taxpayer contributions and private health insurance funding are. Minister Butler asserts the reliance on taxpayer subsidies via the private health insurance rebate, framing it as a foundational pillar insurers must honor. "They need to respect that social licence and this sort of practice damages that," he emphasized, alluding to potential legislative remedies if the sector fails to self-correct promptly.
The response from Private Healthcare Australia, the industry watchdog, reflects an awareness of these challenges and a stated commitment to collaborate with governmental bodies. "When health funds cancel products, it is usually because those products are making a loss," a spokesperson noted, attributing the introduction of pricier options to escalating healthcare costs amidst an inflationary backdrop.
For those following this development from the original article by Kat Wong (AAP), it is clear that the interplay of rising premiums, regulatory frameworks, and consumer impact invite both immediate and sustained attention, guaranteeing an ongoing sector review.
Published:Wednesday, 11th Dec 2024
Source: Paige Estritori
![]() | Australia’s Insurtech Rise: Pioneering Innovation in Insurance 12 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian insurtech sector is steadily gaining prominence with innovative products aimed at boosting efficiency, security, and customer interaction. According to a recent report titled 'Insurtech Down Under: Trends, Tech and Triumphs,' the sector's growth is accelerating, supported by strategic investments and technological advancements. - read more |
![]() | Hacked Company Loses Insurance Battle Over Customer Payment Scam 11 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori A company recently faced a significant setback after losing an insurance claim dispute related to funds stolen in a fraudulent email scheme. Cybercriminals infiltrated the business's email system, sending out fake invoices that directed clients to pay into a bogus bank account. Consequently, two customers inadvertently transferred a total of $66,148 to the fraudulent account. Attempts to retrieve this money were unsuccessful, and the customers refused further payments to the company. - read more |
![]() | Australia Underwriting Rises to Meet Complex Insurance Challenges 11 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori In an evolving insurance landscape where traditional underwriters are hesitant to cover high-risk scenarios, Australia Underwriting has strategically positioned itself to fill this crucial gap. The company has become recognized for its expertise in handling difficult-to-place insurance risks, often ignored by larger insurers focused on lower-risk ventures. Founded by industry veteran George Vincent, the firm has capitalized on unserved market segments and emerged as a vital player in the Australian insurance space. - read more |
![]() | Ombudsman Orders Higher Compensation From Insurer Over Mould Dispute 10 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has directed insurance provider Hollard to enhance its compensation payout to a homeowner following a failed attempt to remediate mould contamination in the owner’s property. Despite previous repair efforts by Hollard, lingering mould issues persisted, prompting further disputes. - read more |
![]() | Insurance Brokers Challenge Opposition’s Divestment Strategy 06 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori Opposition Leader Peter Dutton’s proposal to dismantle major insurance companies to boost competitiveness and reduce premiums has sparked significant pushback from industry brokers. The suggestion, criticized as ineffective, faces opposition from those who argue that the root causes of high premiums lie elsewhere. - read more |
![]() | Navigating Public Liability Insurance for Event Organizers: A Must-Read Guide Event organizing can be an exhilarating adventure, teeming with creativity and collaboration. However, with the buzz of activity and the gathering of crowds comes a significant responsibility to ensure the safety and well-being of attendees, staff, and the venue itself. This is where Public Liability Insurance becomes a pivotal part of an event organizer's toolkit. - read more
|
![]() | Protect Your Construction Business: The Importance of Adequate Liability Coverage Operating within the construction industry involves managing an intricate web of risks and liabilities daily. Public liability insurance stands as one of the core safeguards to protect businesses from potential financial pitfalls that may arise from these risks. - read more
|
![]() | Understanding Public Liability Insurance: A Must-Have for Aussie Businesses For any Australian business, the unforeseeable mishaps that can occur daily pose potential risks not only to operational continuity but also to financial stability. At the core of a strategic risk management plan lies the essential protective layer of public liability insurance, a shield safeguarding businesses from the legal and financial repercussions of accidents and injuries that may happen on their premises, or as a result of their operations. - read more
|
![]() | The Role of Liability Insurance in Managing Contractor and Supplier Risks Engaging with contractors and suppliers is an integral facet of many business operations, fostering growth and expansion. However, with this collaboration comes inherent risks that can impact a business financially and legally, should any unexpected incidents arise. It is here that liability insurance steps in as a cornerstone of risk management, safeguarding businesses from potential pitfalls associated with these partnerships. - read more
|
![]() | The Importance of Public Liability Insurance in Protecting Your Business Public liability insurance is a type of coverage designed to protect business owners against claims made by third parties for injuries or damages that occur in connection with business operations. - read more
|
![]() |
The Role of Public Liability Insurance in Protecting Hospitality Venues Public liability insurance serves as a critical safety net for event organizers, often seen as a robust shield safeguarding against potential financial repercussions arising from unforeseen incidents. In the dynamic atmosphere of events, where a multitude of variables come into play, this insurance plays a fundamental role in ensuring the stability and continuance of the host's operations. - read more
|
![]() |
The Business Owner's Guide to Calculating Adequate Public Liability Coverage For any business owner, navigating the waters of legal and financial protection can be daunting. Public liability insurance is a lifeboat in this respect; by understanding its basics, businesses can better shield themselves against the unpredictable tides of liability claims. As a starting point, public liability insurance is designed to protect businesses in the event that a third party suffers an injury or property damage due to the business's operations. - read more
|
![]() |
Public Liability Insurance for Manufacturers: Are You Fully Covered? Public liability insurance is a cornerstone of protection for businesses, offering a shield against claims for personal injury or property damage inflicted on third parties as a result of their operations. As manufacturers open their doors to employees, suppliers, and sometimes the public, they navigate a landscape rife with potential hazards. Public liability insurance becomes not just a safety net, but an essential aspect of responsible entrepreneurship. - read more
|
![]() |
Understanding Public Liability Insurance for IT Consultants: Risks and Mitigation Public Liability Insurance acts as a shield for businesses, and for IT consultants, it's a safeguard against the unforeseen legal costs and compensation payments arising from third-party claims. As professionals who offer expert advice and services, IT consultants face unique risks that can lead to liability claims. Having public liability insurance not only provides a financial safety net but also serves as a testament to the consultant's responsibility and professionalism. - read more
|
![]() |
Essential Public Liability Coverage for Gym and Fitness Center Owners Running a gym or fitness center comes with unique responsibilities, especially when it comes to providing a safe environment for clients. In this dynamic space, where individuals engage in activities that may pose risks, it is imperative for gym owners to understand the importance of public liability insurance. This type of coverage is a cornerstone for safeguarding your business against claims arising from accidental injuries or property damage to third parties. - read more
|