The homeowner, dissatisfied with earlier repair efforts concluded in May 2023, cited an expert analysis revealing ongoing mould contamination. The analysis detailed "moisture migration" from damp materials on the ground floor contributing to mould growth on the upper levels of the home. A mycologist’s inspection in August 2023 uncovered significant fungal spore concentrations throughout the property, including in the insulation and air-conditioning system.
Subsequent investigations indicated elevated spore levels within key areas such as a bedroom and bathroom. The mycologist conclusively stated that the property was not adequately remediated for mould.
Hollard refuted these findings, asserting repair work was satisfactory and contested the reliability of the homeowner's assessments, which were conducted six to ten weeks after Hollard’s expert, WEC, had reportedly verified the mould issues as resolved. Hollard suggested that any ongoing mould presence could be attributed to external factors, such as the homeowner’s pets or workers.
Conversely, the AFCA panel criticised Hollard’s WEC findings for their lack of specificity, primarily relying on generalized airborne mould testing. In contrast, the complainant's experts provided more comprehensive evaluations evidencing persistent mould issues.
The AFCA noted a contradiction in Hollard’s stance, linking the return of mould to non-claimable factors, as this was not in alignment with its own investigations which attempted to undermine the homeowner's findings of mould.
The authority concluded that Hollard had inadequately addressed the mould issue, likely exacerbated by insufficient containment and delays, allowing its spread to the upstairs area of the property.
In light of these findings, AFCA recommended a fair resolution involving a cash settlement to encompass a renewed scope of works with a 15% contingency increase. Moreover, Hollard is required to fund alternative accommodation while the property remains uninhabitable, compensate for any damage from its repair work, and cover the homeowner’s expert costs.
Additionally, Hollard has been mandated to pay a total of $5,400 in damages—$2,500 for the unresolved mould issue and $2,900 for failing to adhere to an earlier AFCA dispute outcome.
Published:Monday, 10th Mar 2025
Source: Paige Estritori
![]() | Ombudsman Orders Higher Compensation From Insurer Over Mould Dispute 10 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has directed insurance provider Hollard to enhance its compensation payout to a homeowner following a failed attempt to remediate mould contamination in the owner’s property. Despite previous repair efforts by Hollard, lingering mould issues persisted, prompting further disputes. - read more |
![]() | Insurance Brokers Challenge Opposition’s Divestment Strategy 06 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori Opposition Leader Peter Dutton’s proposal to dismantle major insurance companies to boost competitiveness and reduce premiums has sparked significant pushback from industry brokers. The suggestion, criticized as ineffective, faces opposition from those who argue that the root causes of high premiums lie elsewhere. - read more |
![]() | $30 Billion Flood Defence Fund Proposed in Election Agenda 04 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) has unveiled its election platform, urging the federal government to significantly enhance flood defences by establishing a $30.15 billion flood defence fund. This initiative, highlighted as the primary recommendation, seeks to mitigate the catastrophic impact of floods, which are deemed as Australia’s most financially damaging natural disaster. - read more |
![]() | Australians Reconsider Health Insurance As Costs Rise 04 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori New findings from Finder reveal a growing trend among Australians considering the cancellation of their health insurance policies. This move comes in response to increasing living expenses and an impending rise in insurance premiums. - read more |
![]() | Exploring the Future of Insurance at the Outlook 2025 Conference 01 Mar 2025: Paige Estritori The Insurance News Outlook 2025 Conference, scheduled for March 12 in Sydney, is set to delve deeply into the insurance industry's future. With a focus on emerging risks, advancements in technology, and the evolving landscape of broking, the event promises insightful discussions led by industry experts. - read more |
![]() | Public Liability Insurance for Tradespeople: Safeguarding Your Business on Site If you're a tradesperson, safeguarding your business is not just about having the right tools and skills, but also ensuring you're protected against unexpected events on site. Public Liability Insurance plays a crucial role in your safety net, providing a shield against potential financial setbacks caused by accidents and injuries. - read more
|
![]() | Essential Public Liability Coverage for Gym and Fitness Center Owners Running a gym or fitness center comes with unique responsibilities, especially when it comes to providing a safe environment for clients. In this dynamic space, where individuals engage in activities that may pose risks, it is imperative for gym owners to understand the importance of public liability insurance. This type of coverage is a cornerstone for safeguarding your business against claims arising from accidental injuries or property damage to third parties. - read more
|
![]() | Why Retail Store Owners Can't Afford to Skip Public Liability Insurance As the owner of a retail store, you may not realize that the day-to-day interactions with customers and the public pose significant financial risks. Whether it's a customer slipping on a wet floor or a product causing harm, the threat of negligence claims is all too real. This is where Public Liability Insurance becomes not just a safety net, but a fundamental necessity for your business operations. - read more
|
![]() | 5 Things Every Restaurant Owner Needs to Know About Public Liability Insurance Every restaurant owner needs to be familiar with the term 'public liability insurance'. This type of insurance is designed to protect your business financially in case a customer or a member of the public suffers an injury or property damage as a result of your business operations. In a bustling restaurant environment, accidents can happen—the risk of slips, spills, and other mishaps is ever-present. - read more
|
![]() | Navigating Public Liability Insurance for Event Organizers: A Must-Read Guide Event organizing can be an exhilarating adventure, teeming with creativity and collaboration. However, with the buzz of activity and the gathering of crowds comes a significant responsibility to ensure the safety and well-being of attendees, staff, and the venue itself. This is where Public Liability Insurance becomes a pivotal part of an event organizer's toolkit. - read more
|
![]() |
Navigating Public Liability Insurance for Event Organizers: A Must-Read Guide Event organizing can be an exhilarating adventure, teeming with creativity and collaboration. However, with the buzz of activity and the gathering of crowds comes a significant responsibility to ensure the safety and well-being of attendees, staff, and the venue itself. This is where Public Liability Insurance becomes a pivotal part of an event organizer's toolkit. - read more
|
![]() |
The Business Owner's Guide to Calculating Adequate Public Liability Coverage For any business owner, navigating the waters of legal and financial protection can be daunting. Public liability insurance is a lifeboat in this respect; by understanding its basics, businesses can better shield themselves against the unpredictable tides of liability claims. As a starting point, public liability insurance is designed to protect businesses in the event that a third party suffers an injury or property damage due to the business's operations. - read more
|
![]() |
How to Choose the Right Public Liability Insurance Policy for Your Business When it comes to running a business, safeguarding your financial well-being against unforeseen events is crucial. Public Liability Insurance (PLI) is designed to protect your business from the financial risks associated with claims of property damage, personal injury, or death caused to third parties due to business activities. Understanding this shield of security is the first line of defense in a world where accidents and mishaps are not just possible but often probable. - read more
|
![]() |
A Guide to Public Liability Insurance for Construction Businesses When embarking on a construction project, the potential for unexpected incidents and the associated liabilities cannot be ignored. Navigating through the intricate world of insurance might seem daunting, but understanding public liability insurance can save your business from financial peril. In the ever-evolving landscape of Australian construction, its significance cannot be overstated. - read more
|
![]() |
The Role of Liability Insurance in Managing Contractor and Supplier Risks Engaging with contractors and suppliers is an integral facet of many business operations, fostering growth and expansion. However, with this collaboration comes inherent risks that can impact a business financially and legally, should any unexpected incidents arise. It is here that liability insurance steps in as a cornerstone of risk management, safeguarding businesses from potential pitfalls associated with these partnerships. - read more
|