A Vintage Car Owner Faces Claims Rejection After Repair Nightmare

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

The Pontiac, originally purchased from the United States in 2014, was in need of refurbishment to restore its former glory by 2021. In December of that year, the car owner approached a repair shop, designated here as Shop N, which provided a restoration estimate of $12,000. Little did he know that this choice would lead him down a troublesome path.

By July 2022, the owner became increasingly frustrated with the lack of progress on his vehicle. In an effort to reclaim his car, he arranged for a former employee of Shop N, referred to here as Shop C, to retrieve the vehicle. However, he claimed that Shop N refused to release the car, leading him to lodge a theft report with his insurance company, SGUAS.

In a strange twist, the owner later revealed to SGUAS that the vehicle had indeed been found. He stated that Shop C had taken the car after allegedly threatening the repair shop's owner. With the car in Shop C’s possession, the owner paid $6,000 for necessary repairs, believing his vehicle was in capable hands.

Despite assurances that work was progressing smoothly, the owner’s confidence waned when he could not ascertain the storage location of his car. When he visited Shop C’s facility in March 2023, he was informed that his vehicle was unavailable, sparking another theft report when communication broke down.

As investigations unfolded, it became apparent that Shop C had stored the Pontiac in a paid location but had failed to prevent damage from corrosion and missing parts. The insurer SGUAS ultimately denied the owner’s claims, asserting the circumstances did not qualify as theft. They reasoned that since the owner had permitted both Shop N and Shop C to handle his vehicle, it could not be considered stolen.

This ruling, released by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), clarified that while the claim was rooted in distressing events, it did not meet the criteria for theft as defined under the insurance policy. Both repairers were found to have inadequate responses to queries regarding the car's condition, but AFCA concluded that the owner's authorization to the repairers negated the theft claim.

“It is not clear whether the damage is malicious or just a byproduct of negligence,” AFCA detailed in its findings. The report indicated that Shop C, after disassembling parts of the vehicle, exhibited an inability or unwillingness to complete the repairs, further complicating the ordeal.

The AFCA noted, “The situation is significant and distressing for the claimant,” nonetheless confirming that the terms of the insurance policy would not cover the circumstances described. Insurance experts recommend that vehicle owners conduct thorough due diligence before committing to a repair shop, ensuring clear agreements and regular updates throughout the repair process.

For classic car enthusiasts, these cases serve as a stark reminder of the complexities involved in restoration work and the critical importance of safeguarding their investments through comprehensive insurance knowledge and proactive communication with service providers.

Source: Insurance News Magazine

Published:Tuesday, 31st Dec 2024
Author: Paige Estritori

Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Key Challenges Facing Australian Insurers in 2026

07 May 2026: Paige Estritori

As Australian insurers navigate the complexities of 2026, three primary challenges have emerged at the forefront: premium affordability and insurability, cyber and data security risks, and workforce attraction and retention. These insights stem from industry feedback highlighted in Gallagher Bassett's forthcoming report, 'The Carrier Perspective: 2026 Claims Insights'. - read more

ACCC Scrutinises IAG's Proposed Acquisition of RAC Insurance

07 May 2026: Paige Estritori

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has commenced a detailed Phase 2 review of Insurance Australia Group's (IAG) proposed acquisition of RAC Insurance. This move follows concerns that the merger could substantially lessen competition in Western Australia's insurance market, particularly in motor vehicle and home and contents insurance sectors. - read more

ASIC's Actions Following Shield Collapse Transform Insurance Compliance

07 May 2026: Paige Estritori

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has outlined a series of enforcement and surveillance measures in response to the collapse of Shield and First Guardian. These actions are set to significantly reshape the compliance and governance landscape for insurers, particularly in their roles as underwriters, superannuation partners, institutional investors, and Australian Financial Services (AFS) licensees. - read more

Ocean Underwriting Introduces Tailored Liability Solutions for High-Risk Occupations

29 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori

Ocean Underwriting has unveiled a new facility designed to support complex or hard-to-place liability risks, particularly targeting higher-hazard occupations with unique exposures. This initiative aims to provide tailored insurance solutions that address the specific needs of businesses operating in challenging sectors. - read more

Surge in Professional Indemnity Claims Hits Financial Services Sector

29 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori

The financial services industry is currently experiencing a significant uptick in professional indemnity (PI) claims, a trend largely attributed to heightened regulatory scrutiny and enforcement actions by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). This development has substantial implications for financial professionals and their insurers. - read more

Click for more Insurance News