Ombudsman Upholds Policyholder’s Claim Despite Fraud Allegations

A motor insurance policyholder has won a significant dispute over fraud allegations, with the industry ombudsman ruling in favour of a payout following a controversial car accident claim.

The case revolved around an incident where the claimant's wife crashed at an intersection one evening, reportedly failing to yield.

The lack of photographic evidence due to shock and subsequent involvement of towing services complicated matters.

Suncorp, the insurer, challenged the legitimacy of the claim, citing inconsistencies in the timeline regarding the husband’s arrival at the crash scene. Additionally, the absence of a police report, unreachable towing service contacts, and testimony from local residents indicating no observed accident raised suspicion. Suncorp’s investigator even found no crash evidence at the claimed location, while a forensic expert suggested the vehicle might have been stationary when hit and noted the absence of seat belt use.

The policyholder's attempts to alter the car's insurance value compounded the insurer's doubts, particularly following a failed attempt to substantially increase its sum insured. Despite these allegations, the vehicle was insured for $52,000, down from the attempted $75,000 adjustment.

However, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) countered with indications that the couple had few financial motives, presenting modest savings and no debts. AFCA accepted that crash site cleanup in residential areas is understandable and argued Suncorp misapplied its forensic interpretations. Though recognising inconsistencies in the couple’s story, AFCA concluded they weren't significant enough to warrant rejecting the insurance claim.

AFCA underscores the importance of fair consideration in insurance claims and stresses that discrepancies in personal testimonies during traumatic events should be weighed with care.

Moving forward, this ruling might prompt insurance companies to reassess their investigative approaches and criteria for claim rejection based on circumstantial evidence. Such cases highlight the delicate balance insurers must maintain between vigilance against fraud and the fair treatment of policyholders.

Published:Monday, 8th Sep 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Cyber Insurance Becomes Essential Amid Rising Digital Threats

12 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

The recent cyberattack on Fortnum Private Wealth, accompanied by ASIC's legal action, has spotlighted the critical risks cyber threats pose to financial advice companies in Australia. With digital integration intensifying across the finance sector, the owner of Fortnum, Entireti, plans to defend the case, underscoring the necessity for ongoing vigilance in cybersecurity measures. - read more

Swiss Re Foresees Rising Premiums Amid Increasing Global Risks

10 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In a comprehensive analysis, Swiss Re Institute predicts that global property and casualty insurance premiums will rise in tandem with GDP over the upcoming decade. This growth is driven by amplified natural catastrophe losses, asset accumulation, and heightened economic and litigation claims inflation. The institute's report outlines the evolving insurance landscape amid increasing global risks. - read more

Insurance Council of Australia Assists NSW Flood Claimants

09 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In response to the devastating floods that swept across New South Wales' Mid North Coast in May, the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) is taking proactive steps to support the affected residents. Insurers, organised by the ICA, will be meeting with flood victims in Kempsey, Taree, and Port Macquarie to provide guidance and support as they navigate their insurance claims. - read more

Ombudsman Upholds Policyholder’s Claim Despite Fraud Allegations

08 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

A motor insurance policyholder has won a significant dispute over fraud allegations, with the industry ombudsman ruling in favour of a payout following a controversial car accident claim. The case revolved around an incident where the claimant's wife crashed at an intersection one evening, reportedly failing to yield. The lack of photographic evidence due to shock and subsequent involvement of towing services complicated matters. - read more

NM Insurance Secures Growth with Five-Year Zurich Partnership

05 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In a strategic move set to bolster its market position, NM Insurance has announced a five-year agreement with capacity provider Zurich, positioning itself for further growth and increased broker confidence in its success. Since its establishment two decades ago as Nautilus Marine Insurance Agency, NM Insurance has expanded its focus beyond the recreational boat market in Australia, branching into New Zealand and diversifying into the commercial marine, caravan, and motorcycle sectors. - read more

Click for more Insurance News

Business Insurance Articles

Protect Your Construction Business: The Importance of Adequate Liability Coverage

Operating within the construction industry involves managing an intricate web of risks and liabilities daily. Public liability insurance stands as one of the core safeguards to protect businesses from potential financial pitfalls that may arise from these risks. - read more

The Difference Between Public Liability and Other Insurances Explained

Public liability insurance is designed to protect businesses against claims made by the public for injuries or damages that occur in connection with the business operations. It covers legal fees, medical expenses, and compensation costs that may arise if a customer or a member of the public is injured or property is damaged as a result of the business activities. - read more

Why Retail Store Owners Can't Afford to Skip Public Liability Insurance

As the owner of a retail store, you may not realize that the day-to-day interactions with customers and the public pose significant financial risks. Whether it's a customer slipping on a wet floor or a product causing harm, the threat of negligence claims is all too real. This is where Public Liability Insurance becomes not just a safety net, but a fundamental necessity for your business operations. - read more

A Guide to Public Liability Insurance for Construction Businesses

When embarking on a construction project, the potential for unexpected incidents and the associated liabilities cannot be ignored. Navigating through the intricate world of insurance might seem daunting, but understanding public liability insurance can save your business from financial peril. In the ever-evolving landscape of Australian construction, its significance cannot be overstated. - read more

The Role of Liability Insurance in Managing Contractor and Supplier Risks

Engaging with contractors and suppliers is an integral facet of many business operations, fostering growth and expansion. However, with this collaboration comes inherent risks that can impact a business financially and legally, should any unexpected incidents arise. It is here that liability insurance steps in as a cornerstone of risk management, safeguarding businesses from potential pitfalls associated with these partnerships. - read more

Knowledgebase

Insurance Premium:
The periodic amount paid for the purchase of insurance.

This website is owned and operated by Clark Family Pty Ltd (as Trustee for the Clark Family Trust) 43 Larch Street Tallebudgera QLD 4228, A.C.N. 010281008, authorised Financial Services Representative of Unique Group Broker Services Pty Ltd, Australian Financial Services License 509434. Visit the ASIC website for additional licensing information.

IMPORTANT: We are neither authorised nor licensed to provide finance or finance products. We do not recommend any specific financial products and we do not offer any form of credit or other financial advice. All product enquiries and requests for financial and/or other advice on this website are referred to third party, qualified intermediaries with whom you can deal directly. We may receive a fee or commission from these third parties in consideration for the referral. Before any action is taken to obtain a product or service referred to by this website, advice should be obtained (from either the third part to whom we refer you or from another qualified intermediary) as to the appropriateness of obtaining those products having regard to your objectives, financial situation and needs.